DON’T SELL YOUR HOME!
Advice few agents will ever give you.
by Neil Jenman
READING TIME: APX 11 mins
This happened years ago. But the message still applies today – maybe more so.
I came bounding into my real estate office. There was a man at our reception desk. His face was familiar.
“G’day Neil,” he said. “You don’t remember me, do you?”
I did what most agents do – and what I often tell agents not to do.
I looked at him and said, “Lavinia Street.”
Shamefully, I remembered his street name not his surname.
His name was Dan Dickens. He told me his story – and why he had come to see me on this day.
“Seven years ago,” Dan said, “You came to see my wife and me. We decided to sell our home in Merrylands and move to Coffs Harbour. Out mind was made up – or at least mine was. We were set to go. We were just looking for the best agent to handle our sale.
“You started to ask us questions. But vastly different questions compared with other agents. You quizzed us about Coffs Harbour. I said we’d holidayed there for 25 years. Now that our children were grown-up, we were free to retire to Coffs. I told you how I loved fishing. Especially on the Bellinger River.”
You asked us if we had any grandchildren. Our first had just been born. My wife was rapt. I was chuffed too. Three of our four children had married in the past three years – and the fourth had just got engaged. You told us that we’d soon be grandparents to many little-uns.
When you talked about our own children giving us grandchildren, my wife’s face lit up. You then asked a very personal question. Do you remember?”
“Well,” I said, “I probably asked: What’s more important – fishing or grandchildren?”
“You got it,” Dan said. “That’s exactly what you asked. You then talked us out of selling our home. You told us that we could still go fishing in the holidays, but if we kept our home, we could have our children and our grandchildren full-time. You may remember my wife gave you a hug.
“Well Mr Jenman, for the last seven years my wife has mentioned you constantly. I can’t tell you how many mornings she got up and thanked God you talked us out of selling our home.”
He then said: “My wife passed away last month. Two of our children are now in Queensland. I want to move there. So, this time, Mr Jenman, you must sell my home. I won’t be interviewing any other agents. You are it.”
‘STAY PUT’ IF YOU’LL BE LESS HAPPY
Dan and his wife were not the only home-owners I talked out of selling. I often told people to stay put. Especially if they were going to be less happy if they sold.
The most common reaction I got was: “But you are an agent. You only get paid if we sell. You get nothing if we don’t sell. Why would you tell us not to sell?”
I gave each home-owner the same answer: When I got into real estate, I made two strong promises – like vows. The first was to work very hard. And the second promise was to always do what’s in the best interests of the home-owners.
From my experience in real estate, I can confidently state the following: Most people who sell their homes – especially family homes – feel sad. In some of those cases – a surprisingly high number, actually – the home-owners would be happier, much happier, if they stayed put.
ELDERLY HOME-OWNERS
This particularly applies to elderly people, many of whom are pressured into selling by relatives. They are constantly told they are “getting old” – which they know. They are then told that the home is “too much for them”.
In what way? And in whose opinion?
Many times, when I appraised homes of elderly people, my gentle questioning would lead to them almost breaking down with sadness at the mere thought of selling.
In some cases, I would call their children – or grandchildren – and ask if they could help their parents or grandparents with maintenance. After all, the beneficiaries are going to inherit the home when their elderly relatives pass away.
And, as the saying goes, “Where there’s a will, there’s a relative.”
Many relatives are eager to line-up and pocket the proceeds of a home sale when old folk pass away. But those same relatives are not so keen to line-up and mow lawns or clear gutters when the old folk are still living – and battling to keep their home.
Recently, a man in his late 70s told me what many men of his vintage state: “Every time I use the whipper-snipper, my back aches for days.”
Back pain from the strain of gardening was his main reason for selling his home.
Now, please understand: Selling a home is not cheap – especially commission these days. It’s common for elderly folk to pay more than $50,000 to an agent for “selling” their home. Plus a few thousand dollars in needless advertising costs which benefit agents more than sellers.
And then, if the sellers will be buying again after they sell (they must live somewhere), they will be up for tens of thousands of dollars in stamp duty. In addition to legal fees.
I did some specific calculations for the man with the aching back. I then said: “For what it will cost you to sell your lovely home on its landscaped block and move to a smaller home, you could hire a gardener three days a week until you are 135 years of age.”
He laughed and kept his home.
RETIREMENT HOMES ARE NOT FOR EVERYONE
Moving into a retirement home – or, sadly, a nursing home – can have a devastating psychological effect on some people. Even if they think they will “be okay”, to be surrounded by scores of other elderly folk, many of whom are ill and, inevitably, passing away, is not good for anyone’s mental health.
Now, to be sure, some elderly folk – my mother-in-law (at 89) is one – are okay moving out of their former family home into a retirement home. But my wife was so sentimentally attached to the home in which she spent her childhood, that, when it was time for her mother to move, she and I bought the home. It stayed in the family.
Most elderly folk want to hang on to their family homes if humanly possible. Often, however, their relatives are the ones to announce that “it’s time”. The trauma of the moving can literally kill some elderly folk.
Therefore, I say: Before you instantly acquiesce and sell your beloved family home, see if you can find a way to keep it. Can you find a relative to help you with gardening and maintenance? If they will inherit the home, pressure them to help you keep your home. Don’t allow them to pressure you to go.
Indeed, don’t let anyone – especially agents – pressure you into selling a home you love. One of the saddest cases I have ever encountered is a delightful lady in the gorgeous Sydney suburb of Bronte. About four years ago, her husband – together with a local agent who was clearly hungry for commission – bullied this lady into selling her beloved family home.
It is no exaggeration to say that this lady has been severely depressed every day since selling her home. She is consumed with regret, anger, and heartbreak. It’s awful. If only she had waited. If only she had thought it over. If only she had resisted the high-pressure.
If you are being pressured by any agent, tell them to go away. I love it when I hear an elderly person say, “I’ll be carried out of here in a box.” That’s how I’m going with my home.
Selling a home is not just expensive financially, it’s also one of the most psychologically stressful events in any person’s life. Indeed, the word ‘home’ is the second most emotive word in the English language (after “mother”).
Many people who sell their homes, don’t feel as if they have sold their home. They feel like they have lost their homes.
MOVING NORTH.
Queensland has always been a popular destination for home-sellers. Now it’s more popular than ever. Since the pandemic people are leaving Sydney and Melbourne in droves. Indeed, twice as many people are leaving these two cities as are migrating to them.
Brisbane is their favoured destination.
But what happens when someone sells their family home in Sydney or Melbourne, moves to Brisbane, and doesn’t like it? Maybe they miss their families. Or their friends. They long to be back in the community they lived-in and loved for decades. It happens – surprisingly often. And many of these northern migrants can’t afford to buy back into their former home-city of Sydney or Melbourne. They are then locked-out of their true home.
Here’s what I used to tell people when I had my real estate office and they wanted to pack-up in Sydney and move to Queensland. I still tell them today. Everything looks good on paper. The glossy brochures of the Sunshine State are enticing.
But how do you know, for sure, that you are going to be delighted with your decision to move north?
No one knows for sure, until they make the move, whether they are going to be glad or sad.
So, here’s what to do.
TRY BEFORE YOU BUY
Instead of taking the often-irreversible step (cost-wise) of selling your home down south and buying up north, you should rent out your home down south. Then rent a home up north.
It’s a darned sight cheaper – and less final – to rent out your own home, then rent another home. And see if you like living in the Sunshine State.
Here’s what I have found: In nearly half the cases where people “try before they buy”, they return to their roots. They miss their former life down south – whether it be family or friends or footy at the MCG – and can’t wait to return.
Few agents will advise people who are “thinking of selling” to do anything other than sell. So, be careful who you ask. Some agents are skilled at almost ejecting home-owners from their homes. They will come at them with a ‘once-in-a-lifetime’ huge offer.
But the reason someone offers a great price for your home is because you own a great home.
Swap the home you love for cash in the bank – or another (lesser) home in another area – and you may feel about as miserable as you’ve ever felt in your life.
Ask most people who sold a family home they once loved, and they will tell you they wish they had kept it. So, if possible, always see if you can find an alternative to selling. And certainly, don’t rush. The agent will still be hovering (circling) whenever you want to sell.
And so will high-paying buyers.
So, here’s the message for anyone thinking of selling a family home they love: Don’t sell your home. Unless you have thought it over at great length – preferably with people who are not going to pocket thousand of dollars if you sell. Be sure that you are going to be happier in your new home than you are in your beloved old home.
We’ve all heard the saying: “Home is where the heart is.”
So, here’s a question for you to consider before you decide whether to sell or not: How much is your heart worth?
So, unless you really must: Don’t sell your home.
IMPORTANT: If you absolutely must sell your property, be sure you do what many sellers are doing: Contact Jenman Support on 1800 1800 18 or support@jenman.com.au. We’ll help you find an agent that gets you the best result and charges nothing until you’re happily sold.
AGENTS NOTE: If meet our client-care standards, please contact us. Thousands of sellers who visit our website need ethical and competent agents.
******************
To comment on this article, please click here.
To contact us, please click here.
To follow Neil on Twitter, please click here.
To visit our Facebook page, please click here.
To read more Articles, please click here.
******************
Belinda
September 1, 2022 @ 9:39 am
I love reading your articles.
There is so little integrity in the world, especially in real estate. It brings me joy to read something written by someone who so clearly upholds and champions having a respectable moral code.
Thank you.
Neil
September 1, 2022 @ 7:23 pm
That is very kind of you Belinda. Comments such as yours are the best “payment” I ever receive.
Mike Powell
September 1, 2022 @ 2:43 pm
Thankyou so much Neil,this our current situation to a ti. You have made our decision to withdraw our house from the depressed Sydney market so much easier.
Absolutely insightful article. Cheers. Mike and Deb
Neil
September 1, 2022 @ 7:18 pm
Thank you for your nice comment. My wife just laughed and said there is going to be a lot more agents peeved with me – again. 😁
Bob Macfarlane
September 1, 2022 @ 3:39 pm
Another thoughtful and insightful article. I enjoyed reading it I don’t know how you keep them coming, but don’t stop.
Neil
September 1, 2022 @ 7:14 pm
Thank you for your nice words, Bob. I feel so indebted to the many home-owners who chose me when I had a real estate agency. Aside from my wife, the real estate public are the reason I’m financially secure. I owe them (you) so much that I will always strive to tell you the deepest truths. It’s how I repay you.
Frank
September 1, 2022 @ 5:11 pm
“Don’t Sell Your Home” is fantastic honest down to earth advice. Unfortunately a timely article personally for myself. I have always lived in the family home in Melbourne & do not own any real estate.
Eight years ago I retired & it was then, that my father encountered health issues. In his later years, he was dependent upon me for his care and well being. With an interstate itinerant only brother and his two adult children living interstate (Coffs Harbour NSW) or overseas I received very little support from other family members. As I have a physical disability, my father had concerns that I would not be able to maintain the family home hence, the sale wish in his Will. Real estate prices most likely means that I will not be able to “buy” my brother’s half share of the house. If money was not an issue, this would not be a problem. At this stage, I would prefer to stay in the family home.
A move to Coffs Harbour is a big decision & issues to consider are :
– Would I be able to cope with a hot humid climate summer?
– What about climate change impacts in that region?
– Are medical and health services readily & easily accessible compared to Melbourne ?
– Buy a villa etc. in my existing Melbourne suburb & try out Coffs Harbour by renting etc.?
Any comments, advice and your “words of wisdom” welcomed.
Thank you
Kind Regards
Frank
PS I have your books “Don’t Sign Anything” & “88 Reasons…..”
Neil
September 1, 2022 @ 7:19 pm
Because your questions are personal, I will respond to you in private. Thank you.
Kind regards,
Neil
Paul Fletcher
September 1, 2022 @ 7:29 pm
Without doubt, that would be your best article.
Well said and thank you.
Martin Storey
September 2, 2022 @ 4:30 am
great article Neil
Unfortunately many homes become nightmares because of the neighbours with all their modern noisy machines, especially when the council has allowed high density dwelling in areas that use to be much lower density.
While the home may be nice and comfy, the neighbourhood has become intolerable, which is why we sold.
Would love to catch up with you sometime,
Martin and Angela Storey
Tonya Kokkolis
September 4, 2022 @ 5:10 pm
Great advice!
Terry Laybourne
September 7, 2022 @ 12:37 pm
Niel, we recently went through the process of deciding whether to sell our home. Mary and I have lived in our home for over 30 years. It is the home we designed and built. We are on a bush block of 5Ha and have used the principles of permaculture to develop the block to entice the wildlife – we have put our hearts and souls into making it what it is today. However, we went through the process you have mentioned – “Is it getting too much for us?” A sister and her husband went through the same process and have now “downsized” and are happy with their decision. We used two agents that you had on your list and we are glad we did. They were both very good and thorough with us and at no point did they “pressure us into selling”. After our meeting with the second agent, Mary and I sat down and went through all the positives and negatives of staying here. In the end the positives of staying here significantly won the day. I don’t feel I could live anywhere else and I quite like the idea of becoming part of the landscape when my time finally comes. Thank you for all your articles – much appreciated.
Sue Morton
September 13, 2022 @ 12:24 pm
Neil,
I loved reading your story/advice. We’ve been inundated with agents lately asking us if we’re interested in selling. We are in our late 70’s. My husband’s response is as yours, the day I leave this house will be in a wooden box. They surprisingly reply that they hear this a lot, especially from older people.
Yes the gardening is getting a bit harder, but when the time comes, we’ll get someone in to do it. We’ve kept it pretty basic so won’t be hard for someone else.
Thank you for your sound advice. We really don’t want to move anyway, and are not being pressured by family to do so. Feel sorry for those that are. Regards Sue and Graham.
Heather Curyer
September 14, 2022 @ 1:30 pm
Fantastic I agree
Also, when people move due to relationship issues (looking for a new start) the couple encounter the same issues in a new location
Plus they have had to foot the bill for moving and stamp duty Stay put and go to a councillor
Mel Sowden
September 15, 2022 @ 10:55 am
A. Story that appeared in the West Australian quite some time ago; Italian migrant retired from working as a miner in Meekatharra(a town not noted for it’s high life and vibrant cafe culture) with his wife couldn’t wait to go back to Italy after many years there,was home for just a short while before busting to get back to Meeka.Think he was lucky and got his place back
Tom
September 17, 2022 @ 6:01 am
That’s about the best advice I’ve ever read . I’m 76 and get a sore back after using the whisper snipper. I’m close to my GP and Cardiologist. 1 1/2 hrs from beach . 15 min by ambulance to Calvary Hospital. 2 of my 4 children are here and 2 of my 4 grandchildren are here. We can all fit together in our home for gatherings . I love my bed and it’s too heavy to move. Will have exciting gardening weekends with barbecue .
Ron
September 20, 2022 @ 4:57 pm
Your articles always have honest inspiring messages to stay safe while it is becoming so difficult not to be scammed. I love your selfless dedicated work which has benefitted so many to live a better safe and secure life. Ron and Jan