AGENT BUSTED FOR INSIDER TRADING

The price of insider trading in Victoria.

Article originally published OCTOBER 25, 2005 –Reviewed and approved.

By Neil Jenman

Simon Lukauskas is a Melbourne estate agent. Sorry, make that “was” an estate agent.

Yesterday (October 25), the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT), found that Simon had committed eight breaches of the Estate Agents Act. He was fined and lost his real estate license.

But, according to Simon, it was all an “unintentional mistake”.

Here’s what happened.

A 91-year-old lady decided to sell her home. Simon was appointed as her estate agent.

Simon described himself as an award-winning salesperson with “levels of professionalism, integrity, honesty, commitment and passion that no other agent can match.”

Just the sort of agent that elderly folk need.

Simon told the lady’s granddaughter that “a naïve young couple” wanted to buy her grandma’s property for $160,000. All was agreed and the property was sold.

It turned out, however, that the home was worth closer to $200,000 and that the buyer was Simon’s flat mate – who later became his lover. Perhaps the sale ignited a romance.

Simon’s employers, Hocking Stuart, were not as starry-eyed as the nouveau-riche flat mate. They fired him and reported him to Consumer Affairs Victoria.

And that’s how Simon ended up at the Tribunal yesterday, his career in tatters. But it was all a mistake, according to Simon.

How so?

In Victoria there are strict laws about agents and their family members buying homes from their clients. Consumer Affairs Victoria are known to pounce on insider traders.

But Simon Lukauskas didn’t think the law applied to flat mates. Such a simple mistake but such a glaring example of how some agents focus on the legal law while ignoring moral laws.

Consumer Affairs wanted a five-year disqualification and a five-thousand-dollar penalty. Fairly mild for costing a ninety-one-year-old lady around $40,000. Bag snatchers get stiffer penalties when they take hundreds from old ladies, never mind thousands.

The Tribunal said his lack of remorse and his failure to accept that the property had been undersold were “factors which indicate a high rather than a low penalty”.  Quite right.

Simon Lukauskas was fined $2,000 and lost his license for two years.

Huh? Another mistake, surely?

No, more like a joke.

*****************

To call Jenman Support, click here 1800 1800 18
To contact us, please click here.
To comment on this article, please click here.
To follow Neil on Twitter, please click here.
To visit our Facebook page, please click here.
To read more Articles, please click here.

*****************

PLEASE NOTE: Our focus is upon helping consumers. Abuse from agents on our web site or Facebook page will be deleted, ignored or well publicised – it depends on our mood.

But one thing will never vary: We will never stop doing what we love most – helping polite and honest consumers get the best deal possible in real estate. And, of course, if any agents are serious about taking care of consumers, we’ll help you too. Thank you.

Comments

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    MYSTERY SHOPPING YOUR AGENT

    How to quickly discover the truth by Neil Jenman READING TIME: Apx 2 mins If you look back on your life, you may find that your biggest mistakes happened when…
    Read more

    THE BEST WAY TO SELL YOUR HOME

    Highest Price, Lowest Cost & No Risks By Neil Jenman Australia’s trusted real estate author   Selling a home is one of the most stressful events in life. But there…
    Read more

    THE $50,000 DISCOUNT QUESTION

    How one question saves buyers thousands of dollars by Neil Jenman READING TIME: 7 mins (apx) Nothing upsets me more than injustice. My dislike of unfairness goes back to the…
    Read more

    WHY DO AGENTS ‘STALK’ HOME-OWNERS

    Understanding what’s really going onby Neil JenmanREADING TIME: Apx 3.5 mins “Stop harassing me! Honestly, you guys are like stalkers. Knocking on my door, telephoning me, leaving flyers in my letterbox.…
    Read more

    SELL WITH CONFIDENCE 

    Our free service protects you with ongoing support during your sale, finds you the highest quality agent and helps get you the HIGHEST PRICE.
    GET MY NO SALE NO FEE GUARANTEE
    Neil Jenman
    Author - Neil Jenman
    AGENT BUSTED FOR INSIDER TRADING - Jenman Support